In the summer of 2018, the group of trans people who had surgery with Dr. Dugi in Portland met with OSHU to discuss how the hospital could provide more trauma-informed care for its trans patients. 17 Mar 2023 07:18:01 It was the spring of 2017 and about two weeks prior Carlie, a 34-year-old trans woman, had undergone a vaginoplasty: a surgery sometimes performed after injuries or post-cancer but most commonly associated with transition-related care. Call her office up, ask them why she is allowing an absolute despot like Rumer to continue to have the endorsement of WPATH. . Malpractice suits remain an expensive last resort, and can be difficult to litigate: the law and medicine havent yet found consensus on what constitutes malpractice in trans-affirming surgeries. Every other week there is a new horror account on Reddit where someone comes out who was victimized by this doctor in her genocide against the trans community. I was like, I need to get a vagina before we have a Republican president, she told Jezebel in an interview in the spring of 2018. Their entire staff was also emailed a dossier of Rumers non surface level atrocities and they remained completely quiet, theyre silence is violence. These patients experiences and their difficulty finding recourse arent about one doctor. They dont make themselves available for trainings. Download PDF. I've been in psychotherapy for many months because I basically received a sexual trauma instead of proper surgery with appropriate aftercare. Bottom surgery for both transfeminine and transmasculine people is multidisciplinary in nature, requiring plastic surgical, urological, and gynecological experience. Cis people generally associate transitioning with extensive surgeries, but transition-related surgical procedures are very rarely approved for trans people under age 18. Dr. Rumer butchered me and dealing with her office to get a resolution has been a fucking NIGHTMARE. View attachment 2462301 View attachment 2462306 Stitches left inside the vagina, which had to be removed later by another doctor in a revision surgery: View attachment 2462304 View attachment 2462305. There needs to be a national organization of healthcare professionals. Additionally, Simpson says that Dr. Rumer left excess tissue around the vaginal opening that made dilation extremely uncomfortable. Insurance coverage often dictates where patients receive care, as it did for Danielle, a 42-year-old trans woman who lives in Portland, Oregon, and depends on Medicaid. Despite Dr. Rumers insistence that everything was fine Simpson developed necrosis of the vulva. These are . There is no independent resource where patients can get data on a surgeons complication rate. Rose says theyre still angry about their surgery six years later, and theyre concerned about Dr. Rumer operating on trans people. Crozer Chester Medical Center 1 Medical Center Blvd Chester, PA 19013. Most of her patients including the defendants in an ongoing case are low income an Often, patients rely completely on a surgeons self-reported data. So what can actually be done while our healthcare and legal system continuously fails to protect us from medical grifters like Dr. Rumer? She is represented by Kristy Bruce of The Rubinstein Law Firm LLC in Hamilton, New Jersey. And speaking out after a traumatic experience, in a moment when so few are able to access care, can either be weaponized by anti-trans activists or interpreted by advocates as a step back.
GRS Surgeon Kathy Rumer is using a right-wing legal team to - Reddit Kathy Rumer can no longer call herself an "ally" of our community when she is working with right wing lawyers to silence and intimidate her own patients. Kathy Griffin has made a name for herself in the comedy industry and uses her celebrity encounters to make fans laugh during shows. Carlie had just returned to Louisiana when she went to the movies with her girlfriend and had trouble sitting down comfortably. RT @ShifterofShapes: Dr Kathy Rumer is another "sex reassignment surgeon" who botched countless patients and gave many colostomy bags along with other life long complications. You can also have the pleasure of being labeled as a transphobic troll by either her or her staff in their google reviews as they casually admit to violating HIPAA by going through their patients records to try to witch hunt you. The two had spoken on Skype a few months before the surgery but . Worse yet, her help came from some of the very people we are supposed to trust . Audrina Minto, also known as Arturo Minto, filed a complaint July 2 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. In April, Dr. Rumers counsel attempted to subpoena me in an unrelated libel case, demanding I hand over all notes, emails, documents and research related to this story. Because right now, they dont certify in specific disease conditions, so to speak., Currently the American Society of Plastic Surgeons has general board certification, but nothing specific to gender-related surgeries, meaning affiliated surgeons wouldnt have to meet specific training standards in order to operate on the genitalia of transgender patients. Missed the final consultations of the season? Partners, caregivers, etc, with a legitimate interest in surgery may post if it's of clear benefit to a trans individual or the community. Despite all of this Marci has remained mostly silent. I just joined Reddit so I could get help. For the people Jezebel spoke to who said they experienced poor surgical outcomes, there wasnt much opportunity to get answers. I have a mystery wound hole. A few months later, she said she never said that. Rule 5: This sub is by and for trans people. Our sisters at Stonewall would have never accepted Rumer or her allies and neither should we. I CAN NOT STRESS THIS ENOUGH. (mass reporting these false positive reviews is also an option) Google means alot to Rumer, let's declaw her on this front. Oct 2020 - 1-year update: Kathy (or someone from her staff) found this post and emailed me to complain about it only 20 days after it was posted (and after around 2 years of complications at that point). A week after the conversation with Dr. Rumer, Carlie says she visited a local gynecologist, who was alarmed and brought Carlie to Oschner Baptist Hospital in New Orleans for emergency surgery. A subreddit devoted to transgender issues pertaining to male-to-female or AMAB people. Dr. Rumer told me originally that I needed surgery under twilight sedation, then she said she didn't say that, and then she later told me I needed major surgery under general anesthesia at Hahnnemen University Hospital (which I think actually closed now!). While the OSHU patients negotiated with hospital officials over possible reforms, some former patients of Dr. Rumer have taken more extreme action. Until the powerful grow the spine to finally speak up the onus falls upon us to be the vanguard and defend our community from Rumer.
RUMER COSMETIC SURGERY - 105 Photos & 21 Reviews - 105 Ardmore Ave News - When Surgeons Fail Gender Confirmation Procedures for Their We now have urologists, gynecologists, and micro-surgeons of all kinds who are involved in genital reconstruction.
Urgent help needed. Dr. Rumer botched my surgery 2 years ago - Reddit Dr. Kathy Rumer, DO - Cosmetic, Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery Once the Obama-era policies were implemented and more trans people could pay for these procedures with insurance or Medicaid, some hospitals rushed to meet the pent-up demand. Get botched by the butcher, get sued if you speak out. It was help that never materialized. Kathy Rumer is no ally of the trans community in a time when republicans are actively rolling back abortion and LGBTQ rights. The details of the arbitration proceedings and their outcomes are not public; none of the plaintiffs in the cases against Dr. Rumers practice returned multiple requests for an interview. If you have any questions, or would like to setup a phone, Skype or in-person consultation with Dr. Rumer, please send us a message using the form below. She holds degrees in mathematics, engineering and . One of the ways we create uniform standards has to be an open exchange of ideas, says Dr. Ting, of Mt. Congressperson Rep. Jamie Raskin has been taking an interest in Rumers SLAPP suits and abuses and would love to hear from you. And even then, website administrators are sometimes nervous to host negative remarks against a specific surgeon, fearing a potential libel suit. and our According to Brittanica, the Oak Park, Illinois native began her . The subpoena demanded I turn over all notes, emails, documents and research referencing Dr. Rumer or her practice. (Like Alexis Lake, these guys are also deserving of some free publicity.) Infections occur, tissue necrosis, dehiscences, those things occur with any surgery, he says. We would mostly suggest putting pressure on Sultan Shakir, the sitting president of Mazzoni, We highly recommend calling the health center despite this. And I think at some point there will be a governing board of some form, probably in the next five to ten years. alleging that the . Are You Awesome at Social Media? Google: delaware-valley-aesthetics-pllc-v-john-doe. I'm basically winging it and referring back to old notes as I type it, but I'm not exactly the most mentally sound at the moment. Her office is horrible at handling insurance. Kathy is having some hesitations before her double operation.. On Tuesday's episode of Botched, Dr. Paul Nassif agrees to repair patient Kathy's nose and perform a revision facelift after she . Just prior to publication, Dr. Rumer again declined to comment and through her attorney threatened to add Jezebel to her pending libel suit. I honestly lost a ton of weight from severe depression. Share Jezebel spoke with several other patients of Dr. Dugi, who together ended up filing an official complaint with the hospital. But Danielle says this whole thing just sabotaged a whole year of work within the Portland trans community, adding that while things didnt turn out ideally, she doesnt regret her surgery. Our surgeons strive for perfection, but occasionally there are complications, he says. Kathy Rumer is an experienced plastic surgeon and surgical specialist who operates out of Ardmore, Pennsylvania. Without that key element, insurance coverage questions are left to regional decision boards, often comprised of insurance company representatives and public health officials who may harbor anti-trans beliefs they want to institutionalize.
Rumer - Transgender Surgery in Philadelphia with Gender Reassignment She told me something, and then said she didn't say it. https://jezebel.com/when-surgeons-fail-their-trans-patients-1844774990?rev=1597854733082. Dr. Rumer is a leading aesthetic & reconstructive plastic surgeon who specializes in Gender Reassignment Surgery. It kept accruing secretions and urine and got really smelly and I was scared of the thing for like the first year, they say, until I figured out there wasnt supposed to be hair there.. The modern technique for vaginoplasty was developed over 100 years ago in Europe and has been practiced in the United States for at least the last 50 years. I think this will be my only update. Dont feel comfortable putting public pressure on Rumer and her enablers and still want to help? To try to fill the gap, people like Dr. Schechter and other doctors who specialize in gender-affirming care have come together to argue for a more standardized training system for hospitals looking to expand into the field. Over time, we have participated in several in-person meetings with individuals and groups. I'm a 35-yr old trans-woman. During this time numerous calls from Carlies mother and her OBGYN to Dr. Rumers office went unanswered, both she and her mother say. And that is completely unethical!. Carlie says she saw the doctor briefly before being wheeled into the operating room, but didnt see Dr. Rumer again during her three days of recovery in the hospital. As a surgeon I can tell you every surgeon has bad outcomes, Dr. Ting tells Jezebel. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. That being said, I feel as practitioners in this very small and new field, we have to police ourselves and maintain standards.. In a time when the Trump administration threatens to roll back a decade of progress around trans access to insurance coverage and Medicaid reimbursement, some worry about anti-transition media crusaders leveraging trans medical horror stories into political opposition against transitioning itself, as Heyer did. "A botched rhinoplasty can lead to facially disfiguring results," Dr. Kathy Rumer, a Philadelphia-based aesthetic and reconstructive plastic surgeon who has not treated Bruce, told The ENQUIRER. Dr. Kathy L. Rumer is trusted by her patients for ethical, high quality care. Transgender questions; transgender answers. Dr. Rumer's office doesn't make outbound calls to insurance providers. I used to be able to get to the 4th dot on the medium-size dilator, and the 3rd dot on the largest dilator. Simpsons complaints about Dr. Rumers work are similar to those alleged by other former patients who spoke with Jezebel. That took away my agency, changing around my story like that.. And pursuing formal action against the surgeon isnt going to do anything to make up for what happened., I should have done more, she says, but I just had to move on with my life.. Here is Mazzonis number, call them up and ask them why they wont denounce Rumer and continue to refer patients to her further endangering the community they claim to provide safe gender affirming care to. Constantly shifting insurance plans and laws governing insurers in the U.S. mean that trans people are often anxious to take on such procedures, fearing that while vetting a potential surgeon an insurance company might change its coverage rules. I'm becoming more depressed and asocial. SHE WILL TELL YOU THAT YOU ARE HEALING BEAUTIFULLY UNTIL IT'S TOO LATE. Kathy L. Rumer, D.O. Heyers publication of the OSHU complaint put a serious dent in talks with the hospital, and shocked the post-op patients who had been looking to start a dialogue with the hospital. Jfc. On March 11, the surgeons attorney attempted to subpoena me based on an unfounded assumption that I was coordinating with this John or Jane Doe. I am relieved that more people are becoming aware and it's extremely sad that there are more stories like mine. Give her some free publicity). Patients of Rumer often have to undergo stressful and costly revision surgeries with other doctors. Dr. Kathy Rumer DO is a surgeon in eastern PA who has made a lucrative living performing GCS surgeries, the majority of which are rushed and have shoddy outcomes which leave the patients with lifelong injuries.
AcheJ on Twitter: "RT @ShifterofShapes: Dr Kathy Rumer is another "sex Cookie Notice People really have to go on gut feeling.. She has now consulted with, by her own count, 36 surgeons about fixing her genitalia. But there are few standardized rules around what qualified means, and gender reassignment is plagued by issues that affect other areas of the medical industry. I needed urgent help a year and a half ago. Incredibly unprofessional. A senior advisor to New York's governor, Kathy Hochul, quit on Sunday after reports emerged of him creating a toxic environment. Phone: (855) 782-5665. They went to all these conferences and stuff essentially to do marketing promotion of their work, says Green. Sinai. 1. Since 2016 the blog has intermittently posted figures in Guy Fawkes masks, the doctors home address, and linked to public reports about the surgeons work. In or around 2019, Dr. Rumer discovered a website known as "Kathy Rumer's Anonymous", a . Worse yet, Lake is possibly getting kickbacks for every patient she refers to Rumer.
Petition Kathy Rumer Must Resign Change.org I don't have a fucking vagina. And as a defendant in malpractice suits myself, it is a very uncomfortable topic. Sometimes it smells really bad and I'm extremely embarrased and hate myself. She spent two days in the intensive care unit and five days total at the hospital.
Watch: Dr. Terry Dubrow and Dr. Paul Nassif Dish on Botched - E! Online That seems like her go-to word for every check-up: "beautiful." Most, understandably, declined to comment, but three who wished to remain anonymous had collectively seen more than 50 patients who had originally gone to Dr. Rumer for GRS since 2016. This is not going to be easy for me to write, and it's really personal and gross. Still, such procedures are expensive: It can cost around $25,000 for a vaginoplasty. They graduated from PHILADELPHIA COLLEGE OF OSTEOPATHIC MEDICINE and is affiliated with Lankenau Medical Center, Thomas Jefferson University Hospital and Delaware County Memorial Hospital. She provides comprehensive transitioning surgical procedures to both the male-to-female (MTF) and female-to-male (FTM) transgender communities. When you see a pattern of outcomes that suggests that maybe a surgeon isnt meeting standards of care, then you feel obliged to speak up.. Generally, it results in a loss of tissue in the infected area. Some anti-trans activists create opposition to access to trans-affirming care by claiming treatments are experimental or too risky to be ethical, another obstacle when patients consider speaking openly about their experiences with individual surgeons. https://linktr.ee/resignrumer There is also a subreddit /r/KathyRumer, Need to radicalize a friend who thinks its possible to beat Rumer via the legal game/system? The organization runs its own surgical trainings, which began under Greens presidency from 2014 to 2016. Any lawyers reading this??? According to one source with knowledge of the groups discussions with the hospital, the group felt that the hospitals complication rates were much higher than other hospitals offering similar procedures. I had bottom surgery with Dr. Kathy Rumer in May 2017. (Do not EVER contact me again.) In regards to Mazzoni we also need to make sure Rumer is permanently banned from attending the annual Trans Health Conference (A wonderful place to distribute the new flyers we are currently producing.) According to her website, she is one of the few female board-certified plastic surgeons in the Philadelphia tri-state area, a fellow of the American College of Osteopathic Surgeons, and a site director for the Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine (PCOM) Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery Fellowship. Her staff use sock accounts to post fake positive reviews on almost a weekly basis. If you have an article you like, or a worry to talk about, or you just want to vent a bit about trans life, then we're here! But no board has wanted to take this on.. The answer: It is up to us to hold Rumer and all of the people who protect her accountable. Regardless, restricting access to these procedures is not the answer when there are reforms that could be made to the existing system in order to improve it. These meetings are ongoing until a consensus is reached regarding current patient concerns, the goals of the discussion have been addressed, and plans are in place to prevent recurrence, Dr. Dugi writes in an email. TRIGGER WARNINGS: BOTCHED MEDICAL PROBLEMS. . Rumer Willis Welcomes First Baby With Boyfriend Derek . Share this post! Theres still this sort of very wide variation in how the surgeons are collecting that information and then how theyre reporting it, he said in an interview last year with Jezebel. And why does it take so long before anyone acts? He was expected to testify that even after three surgical revisions, Dr. Rumers work left the plaintiff unable to achieve orgasm or sexual satisfaction without pain, among other significant issues including an oversized clitoris without clitoral hood and hair that hadnt been properly removed. So, sorry in advance. At that time, I also told her that I was bleeding almost every time I dilate for a month. Jezebel was unaware of this website when we began working on this story and all of the people interviewed said they had no prior knowledge of the blog. As a physician nobody likes malpractice suits, says Dr. Ting. Schedule a Consultation Rumer Gender Surgery. Her office accepts new patients. Jezebel spoke to four others who say they experienced issues with surgeries performed by Dr. Rumer, ranging from allegations of poor post-operative care to construction of their vaginas that left them in significant pain or with vulvas that didnt look anatomically correct. In response to several questions from Jezebel, Dr. Dugi says the hospital does not address specific patient interactions because of privacy laws but does admit the staff had several discussions with transgender patients. Carlie chose a surgeon, Dr. Kathy Rumer, who was based in the Philadelphia area and specialized in gender-affirming procedures. On Monday, the office suggested Carlie email photographs of the area of concern so the surgeon could take a look. . I'm not a doctor by any means. Without a set fellowship or apprenticeship guideline from WPATH or any other professional body, theres a broad range of standards for surgeries that patients will have to live with for the rest of their lives. ***********************************************. I'm not ok! In 2017, Dr. Schechter co-wrote an article in the Journal of Sexual Medicine laying out some training minimums for prospective surgeons. (THANK YOU!) I found new doctors thanks to Reddit. That seems like her go-to word for every check-up: "beautiful." In July 2018, I had minor surgery right in her office to remove some granulation tissue. - Kathy Rumer. The subpoena originally asked me to appear at the office of Dr. Rumers attorney in Ardmore, Pennsylvania on April 2, but was subsequently canceled because of the coronavirus pandemic. DO NOT GO TO DR. KATHY RUMER.
Kathy Rumer completely botched this abdominal flap phalloplasty + vaginectomy. According to Schechter, necrosis like Simpson experienced is a risk in any vaginoplasty, and could have been caused by wearing a too-tight undergarment early in post-operative recovery, though it can be difficult to pinpoint exactly what may cause the infection for a given patient. Below are my current symptons. When she posted about her experience with Dr. Rumer on message boards in an attempt to warn other potential patients, Carlies words were reprinted on anti-trans forums. Dr. Dugi tells Jezebel that surgical complications at the hospital are tracked and used to improve outcomes and that their complication rates are in line with or better than the published results of other expert surgeons.
New York Gov Kathy Hochul's political advisor, 42, quits People will always make the choice of fast and cheap over good in some cases, he added more recently. Intersex people who have related surgical interests may post. This level of cruelty against a marginalized community is unbefitting of someone who performatively pretends to advocate for us. alleging that the defendants did not have the appropriate expected from board certified plastic surgeons. After her experience with Dr. Rumer, Carlie decided against a malpractice suit and tried to spread warnings about the surgeon on her own. If you think you can do better, why dont you just give her a vagina?. Many felt that going public about poor results may make it less likely for other surgeons to take on revisions, while official complaints to individual hospitals and state medical boards were lost in bureaucracy, misunderstood, or simply ignored. (650) 570-2270. Dr. Schechter told Jezebel that hospital boards often require that a surgeon be certified by at least one of the 30 or so medical boards across the country and may have varying minimum training standards for potential surgeons. Dr. Rumer is an experienced surgeon: he has run his own practice since 2007, has been treating transgender patients since 2016, and performs up to 400 gender-affirming procedures annually, including facial feminization, breast augmentation and GRS. For her, the violation of privacy was painful. She told me I needed surgery under "twilight sedation" to fix much deeper granulation tissue. Surgeons are accountable to a patchwork of institutions and GRS training can vary between a week of observation with an established surgeon to a years-long apprenticeship program.
In Terms Of Membership, The Knights Of Labor Discriminated,
Articles K